10 Best Heat Resistant Epoxy Resin in The UK

Last updated on 16/08/2025

Advertising disclosure

CRAFT RESIN 4L Table Top Epoxy Resin Kit – 1:1 Mix, Crystal Clear & High Gloss, UV Resistant, Self-Levelling, Food Safe Resin Epoxy 2 Part for Countertops, DIY Casting, Wood & Art Coating

15% OffFree Shipping

Why We Love It

Crystal clear, glass-like finish.
UV resistant for long-lasting use.
User-friendly mix ratio kit.

Main Highlights

Crystal Clear, High Gloss Finish: Our clear epoxy resin kit creates a brilliant, glass-like finish for countertop, bar top, tumblers and art pieces. Designed to maintain clarity without yellowing, it delivers professional results for both beginners and experts.
UV Resistant: Engineered for longevity, this resin epoxy meets rigorous safety standards and is food safe when fully cured. Its superior UV resistance ensures your surfaces remain vibrant and non-yellowing over time.
Self-Leveling & Bubble-Free Formula: With a low 3800 CPS mixed viscosity and natural defoaming properties, our table top epoxy resin self-levels and minimizes bubbles for a flawless, even coat — suitable for casting, coating, and intricate resin art projects.
Fast Cure & Durable Performance: Cures to a rock-hard, scratch-resistant finish within 36 hours and withstands heat up to 203°F, ensuring outstanding durability for indoor and outdoor applications. Recommended pour depth: 1/8 inch.
User-Friendly 1:1 Mix Ratio Kit: This 2-part epoxy kit features a simple 1:1 mix of resin and hardener, complete with detailed instructions and essential mixing tools, making it a perfect solution for DIY crafts, coating and custom art creations.

CRAFT RESIN 1.5L Crystal Clear Deep Pour Epoxy Resin Kit - Food Safe & UV Resistant Best for DIY, Art, River Table, Wood, Flower Preservation, Mould Casting Resin Epoxy Kit - for Beginners & Pros

25% OffFree Shipping

Why We Love It

Deep pour up to 4 inches.
Bubble-free, non-yellowing formula.
Certified and food safe.

Main Highlights

Deep Pour up to 2 Inches - Elevate your art and craft projects with Craft Resin Deep Pour, formulated for safe, single-layer pours up to 2 inches deep. Our premium clear epoxy resin and hardener deliver a stunning, time-efficient glass-like finish with enduring clarity, eliminating the need for multiple pours.
Bubble-Free & Non-Yellowing Formula - Our advanced formula, unique in the epoxy resin market, releases air bubbles effortlessly when warm and offers a longer working time. Say goodbye to bubbles and uneven finishes, ensuring a smooth, consistent result in one go.
Certified & Food Safe - Craft Resin epoxy is minimally odorous, non-toxic, and free from VOCs and solvent materials. As a food-grade epoxy resin, it's perfect for home and professional use, providing safety and environmental friendliness.
Quick Cure & Heat Resistant - Our crystal epoxy resin cures to a rock-hard, scratch-resistant strength in just 48 hours, with heat resistance up to 176°F. It guarantees a crystal clear, glassy smooth finish that lasts for years without cracking or damage from heat.
User-Friendly, 2:1 Ratio Kit - Perfect for beginners, our epoxy resin kits are easy to use and include everything needed for your resin art. The kit consists of clear resin [1L], hardener [0.5L], a reusable mixing stick, pumps, gloves, and a manual, taking your resin art to new heights.

IModeur Epoxy Resin Kit - 128 oz/1 Gallon Self-Leveling Crystal Clear Epoxy Resin - No Yellowing No Bubble UV Resistant Art Resin Casting Resin for Art Crafts, Jewelry Making, Resin Molds (64oz x 2)

29% OffFree Shipping

Why We Love It

Complete epoxy resin kit.
Crystal clear and durable.
User-friendly and UV resistant.

Main Highlights

🍀Complete Epoxy Resin Kit: Our Epoxy Resin is a multipurpose adhesive that offers exceptional strength and durability. It includes 64oz clear resin, 64oz clear hardener, 10 x 230ml/8oz measuring cups, 10 x stirring sticks, 6 x rubber gloves, 2*dropper, 1*scraper, 1*professional user manual. Whether you're working on jewelry making, woodworking, or DIY projects, this epoxy resin is the ideal choice.
🍀Crystal Clear Finish: Achieve professional-looking results with a crystal clear finish. Our epoxy resin have self defoaming self-leveling function, safe and non-toxic, enhancing the beauty of your crafts and providing long-lasting protection. Say goodbye to weak bonds! Our epoxy resin ensures a strong and reliable bond between various materials, including wood, glass, metal, and more. It provides excellent adhesion, allowing your projects to withstand the test of time.
🍀Worry-Free Usage - With a user-friendly formulation, our Epoxy Resin is easy to mix and apply, helps eliminate craters and various other imperfections. Simply follow the instructions provided, and you'll be able to create stunning creations without any hassle. Worried about your crafts fading or yellowing over time? Our AB Epoxy Resin is UV resistant, offering protection against the harmful effects of sunlight and ensuring that your creations maintain their vibrant colors for years to come.
🍀Discover the Ease of Use - Experience the convenience of our 1:1 ratio mixing system. Simply blend the resin and hardener, and you're ready to go! With a generous working time of 40 minutes, it's perfect for beginners, allowing ample time to mix vibrant colors and create eye-catching masterpieces. Unlike many other resins on the market, our Epoxy Resin formula self-levels smoothly, curing quickly within 24-48 hours with minimal to no bubbles.
🍀Unlimited Applications - Ideal for casting, coating, artwork, suitable for bar top, coasters, counter tops, crafts, jewelry making, painting, molds, woodwork, key chains, pens, ashtrays, etc. Let your imagination run wild! With Epoxy Resin, the possibilities are endless. From creating unique jewelry pieces to crafting custom tabletops or decorative items, this epoxy resin opens up a world of creative opportunities.
🍀Important Note - Resin curing time varies based on conditions. It typically dries in 8 hours, cures in 24 hours, and achieves full hardness in 72 hours (longer in winter). Factors like layers, temperature, humidity, and altitude affect curing. After applying the final coat, allow dust-free curing. Avoid temperatures over 120°F to prevent resin warping. Although it hardens in 2-3 days, wait a week before using to minimize light scratching.
🍀Product Warranty - As a customer-first DIY brand, we evenly value the quality of the products and the customer price-performance ratio. Therefore, IModeur has a 90 days-free return policy and a lifetime warranty. If our products have failed your expectations or you’ve encountered any problems, please feel free to contact us.To avoid the biggest problem of resin kit, which is not curing, please read the manual carefully and then test in a small amount before operation.
🍀Safe and Non-toxic - We prioritize your safety, which is why our AB Epoxy Resin is formulated to be safe and non-toxic. You can work on your projects with peace of mind, knowing that you're using a high-quality and safe product.

Teexpert 1,9L High Gloss Epoxy Resin Kit, Upgraded Clear Self-leveling Bubbles-Free Resin Epoxy 1:1 Mix for Casting and Coating, Jewelry Making, Mold, Home Decor, Coaster, Ornament, DIY Crafts

5% OffFree Shipping

Why We Love It

Crystal clear and glossy finish.
Bubble-free and self-leveling.
Easy to use.

Main Highlights

【Crystal Clear & UV Resistant】Achieve stunning results with Teexpert's 2024 upgraded epoxy resin. Our resin is crafted using the safest and purest raw materials, ensuring crystal-clear clarity and a glass-like glossy finish. The inclusion of HALS UV Stabilizer provides unmatched high gloss and a long-lasting shine. our resin's exclusive upgraded high gloss clear anti-UV formula ensures your artwork always remains beautiful. NOT FOR TUMBLER/MUG
【Bubbles Free & Self-Leveling】Say goodbye to bubbles and uneven finishes in your resin projects. Teexpert's Epoxy Resin features a new formula that automatically levels and releases trapped air bubbles, eliminating imperfections such as fish eyes and craters. The result is a perfectly transparent craft with a beautiful, smooth, crystal-clear, and bubble-free finish. Our resin blends seamlessly with pigments and mica powder, allowing you to achieve amazing results.
【Easy to Use & User-Friendly】Our resin boasts a user-friendly 1:1 ratio by volume—simply mix one part resin with one part hardener. It features a unique FAST Curing Resin that provides 45 minutes of work time, allowing you to create your perfect masterpiece. Within 24 hours at room temperature, the resin cures to a durable finish. Suitable for both beginners and professional artists!
【Multi-Application & Durable】Teexpert's premium casting and coating epoxy resin unleash your unlimited potential. After cured, it becomes strong, scratch-resistant, heat-resistant, impact-resistant and highly durable. Use it for resin art, jewelry making, river tables, resin molds, flower preservation, Christmas decorations, and countless other applications. Add unique decorations to your home and personalize your gifts with our versatile resin.
【Low Odor & Safe to Use】Teexpert's resin epoxy formula is non-toxic and safe to use. It is odorless and non-hazardous. We prioritize offering the best and safest resin because we use it ourselves. Our customer support team is available to answer any questions within 24 hours, so please don't hesitate to reach out.

Teexpert Table Top Epoxy Resin, 72OZ/2.1L Epoxy Resin Kit 90℃ Heat Resistant Self-Leveling Easy Coat for Countertop, High Gloss & Crystal Clear for Wood Table, Bar Top, DIY, Art Craft - 2:1 Mix Ratio

Free Shipping

Why We Love It

Exceptional heat resistance guarantee.
Versatile for multiple surfaces.
User-friendly mixing ratio.

Main Highlights

90℃ SUPER HEAT RESISTANT: Our resin coating outperforms others in high heat resistance, enduring temperatures up to 90℃ without dents. While others falter at 60℃, ours remains resilient, even against hot coffee cups. Once fully cured, it achieves an impressive surface hardness of 85D+, surpassing alternatives at 70D+. Top pick for heat-resistant coating resins
PERFECT FOR VARIOUS SURFACES: Teexpert table top epoxy resin is designed for coating a variety of surfaces including table tops, bathroom countertops, bar tops, wood table, surfboards, canvas, coasters, and DIY art crafts. This resin kit offers protection coat against high temperatures and also acts as a protective layer for artwork, shielding it from moisture, scratches, and stains
HIGH GLOSSY COAT FOR A FRESH LOOK: Say goodbye to dull surfaces! Teexpert table top epoxy resin delivers a high-gloss and crystal clear finish, shielding your countertop and art pieces from wear and impact, rejuvenating your countertop with a fresh look. Safe and elegant as a coating solution. Not for casting
SELF-LEVELING & SELF DEFOAMING: Teexpert countertop coating epoxy is self-leveling and self-defoaming, ensuring easy and efficient application, avoiding uneven or sloping surface. It's stain-resistant, moisture-resistant, low odor, and yellow resistant, perfect for coating surfaces like kitchen countertops and trays
EASY TO USE - 2:1 MIX RATIO: This 2 part epoxy resin is beginner-friendly, with a 2:1 mixing ratio by volume, stirring the mixture slowly and thoroughly in one direction for 3-5 minutes until no swirls are visible. At room temperature of 21-26℃, initial curing takes 8-10 hours, and full curing within 24 hours

LET'S RESIN 2.4L Crystal Clear Casting Resin Kit, Bubbles Free Epoxy Resin Kit, Clear Resin for Tumblers, Moulds, Jewelry, Table Top, Epoxy Resin with 6 Mica Powders, Large Silicone Cup and More

25% OffFree Shipping

Why We Love It

Complete starter kit included.
Bubble-free resin finish.
Ideal for various projects.

Main Highlights

All in One Resin Starter Kit: LET’S RESIN epoxy resin includes: 1.2L crystal clear resin + 1.2L crystal clear epoxy hardener, 6 colors mica powders(5g/pack), 1pcs 600ml large silicone cup, 10 pcs small measuring cups and more resin supplies tools, comes with detailed instruction. This resin kit will give you everything need to get started with DIY & Craft Ideas, which is very suitable for professional artists or beginners.
Bubble Free Clear Resin: Our epoxy resin kit formulation contains anti foaming agents, the bubbles will automatically disappear within an hour, cures to a crystal clear finish, superior high gloss compared to other 2 part resin and hard as a rock. And you don’t need to spend a lot of time remove bubble, saving your time.
Crystal Clear Epoxy Resin:This clear resin can be mixed perfectly with any pigments and give the finished product a long-lasting, ultra-clear appearance without yellowing.Ideal for all casting, coating and art projects including jewelry, coasters,tumblers,countertops,table tops,resin art and acrylic pour paintings, molds, river tables.
Safe and easy to use: Our self-leveling epoxy resin are made of safe, and premium materials. With low volatility, virtually odorless. Simple mix resin and hardener in 1:1 volume ratio. Normally you'll need 30-40 minutes working time and 8-24 hours cure time.It's a best gift for families, friends and DIY craft lovers.
Why choose us: Our casting resin has a 1-year shelf life. To avoid the biggest problem of resin epoxy, which is not curing, please read the manual carefully and then test in a small amount before operation. In case it gets damaged during the transportation, such as leakage or partial loss, please do not hesitate to contact us at any time, We will do our best to solve it for you.

LET'S RESIN Casting Epoxy Resin Kit, 1L Crystal Clear & Bubble Free Epoxy Resin and Hardener, High Gloss Resin Kit for DIY Art, Mould Casting, Wood, Jewellery Making, Coasters, Table Top

23% OffFree Shipping

Why We Love It

Easy, bubble-free crafting experience.
Ultimate UV protection guaranteed.
Complete beginner-friendly resin kit.

Main Highlights

UNLEASH YOUR ARTISTIC POTENTIAL - Elevate your creativity with LET'S RESIN. This premium casting epoxy resin and hardener allow you to create stunning pieces with a glass-like finish that remains free from yellowing over time. The self-leveling resin epoxy mixed in a 1:1 volume ratio is easy to operate and requires no experience, even if you are new to resin.
BUBBLE-FREE, NO YELLOWING - Say goodbye to the hassle of bubbles and uneven finishes in your resin projects! Our cutting-edge formula is a true game-changer in the epoxy resin market. Effortlessly eliminate air bubbles as the resin warms up. This casting resin offers UV protection, can be mixed perfectly with any pigments, and give the finished product a long-lasting, ultra-clear appearance without yellowing.
CERTIFIED, SAFE - LET'S RESIN epoxy is perfectly formulated for home and professional use, with low odor and low viscosity, ensuring safety. This epoxy resin has 40 minutes of work time and 24 hours of curing time at room temperature. With a viscosity of 1400CPS, make it easy to mix and pour. The resin can withstand temperatures around 80℃ and is hard as a rock at 85D. Perfect heat-resistant epoxy resin for coasters, ashtrays, and resin light.
ALL YOU NEED IN ONE SET - Our epoxy resin kits for beginners are easy to use. Kits include clear resin (500ml), hardener (500ml), 6 colors mica powders(5g/pack), 4pcs Disposable Measuring Cups, 10pcs Mixing Cups, mixing stick, gloves, manual. Upgrade your resin game and elevate your art to the next level with LET'S RESIN supplies.
WHY CHOOSE US - Our clear epoxy has a 1-year shelf life. To avoid the biggest problem of resin, which is not curing, please read the manual carefully and then test in a small amount before operation.If you have any problems with the product, please contact us. We will do our best to solve it for you.

CRAFT RESIN 1L Crystal Clear Epoxy Resin Kit - Food Safe & UV Resistant for DIY Art, Wood, Jewellery Making, Coasters, Mould Casting Resin Epoxy - Low Viscosity, Self Leveling for Beginners & Pros

20% OffFree Shipping

Why We Love It

Artisan quality for DIY art.
Bubble-free, non-yellowing finish.
Certified, food-safe product.

Main Highlights

ARTISAN APPROVED QUALITY - Unlock your artistic potential with Craft Resin. Premium clear epoxy resin kit and hardener allow you to create beautiful pieces with a glass-like finish and no yellowing over time. Popular for DIY art, tabletop coating, wood, mold casting, canvas, coasters and jewelry making.
BUBBLE-FREE, NO YELLOWING - Are you tired of dealing with the frustration of bubbles and uneven finishes in your resin projects? Our advanced formula is an innovation on the epoxy resin market. Release air bubbles automatically when the resin is warm, recommended depth 1/4 inch.
CERTIFIED, FOOD SAFE - Craft Resin epoxy made with a minimal odor, non-toxic, free of VOCs & solvent materials - food grade epoxy resin perfectly formulated for home and professional use. Harmless to you and the environment, when used as directed.
FAST CURING, HEAT RESISTANT - It takes only 24 hours for our crystal epoxy resin to cure. After this time it becomes rock hard, scratch resistant, advanced additive resistant to heat up to 203℉ (95℃). You’re going to have a crystal clear, glassy smooth finish which will last for years.
EASY TO USE, 1:1 RATIO - Our epoxy resin kits for beginners are simple to use. Kits include clear resin [500ml], hardener [500ml], reusable mixing stick, gloves, manual. Upgrade your resin game and elevate your art to the next level with Craft Resin supplies.

LAMXIN 5 Minute Epoxy Glue 250ml, Tough Durable Heat-Resistant Epoxy Resin Glue, Quick Cure Clear 2 Part Epoxi Adhesives for Metal, Wood, Tile, Most Plastics & More

Free Shipping

Why We Love It

Functional curing in one hour.
Withstand high temperature projects.
Compatible with various materials.

Main Highlights

5 Min Epoxy: Epoxy glue for plastic enjoy the flexibility of approximately 5 minutes of working time, Provide you with enough time to adjust your work creation. Functional curing in one hour, full curing in 24 hours
High Temperature Resistance: Our epoxy adhesive has a high temperature resistant effect and is able to withstand temperatures up to about 300 degrees Fahrenheit (about 149 degrees celsius). 2 part epoxy adhesives can be used for high temperature work without fear of demanding projects
Versatility: This fast curing epoxy adhesives resin is compatible with Metal, glass, wood, concrete, tiles, ceramics, porcelain, 3D printed parts, fiberglass, fabrics and most plastics make it a versatile resin glue of choice
Set Includes: Set contains clear epoxy glue*2, small wooden stick*5, gloves*2 and mixing trays*4. Use the 2 part epoxy glue to mix and stir 1:1 on the mixing trays and say goodbye to complicated operations
Two-Color Bottle Cap: Our clear epoxy glue does not need to be cut, just unscrew the cap and use it. The caps of our two part epoxy glue bottles are different in color. Before use, you can pay attention to the color of the epoxy glue bottle caps to avoid cross-mixing and curing

JDiction Fast Curing Epoxy Resin, 20OZ/600ML 4H Demold Epoxy Resin Kit -Crystal Clear, Bubble-Free, Not-Yellowing, Self-Leveling for Art Resina, Jewelry, Craft, Fast Casting & Easy Mix Epoxy Resina

5% OffFree Shipping

Why We Love It

Cures in 8-10 hours.
Crystal clear and super glossy.
Non-toxic and odorless.

Main Highlights

4 Hours Demold Upgraded Formula: Do you want your artwork to be completed quickly? ? JDiction 4 HOURS DEMOLD epoxy resins new formula is here. Only 8-10 HOURS to FULL CURE, saves you time. You can create more work than others at the same time. This is so exciting!!! This 2 part epoxy resin also offers 2X UV YELLOWING PROTECTION WITH IT’S 2 IN 1 SCIENTIFIC FORMULA.
Crystal Clear & Super Gloss!!: Our epoxy resin crystal clear. JDiction Epoxy Resin is formulated in the USA, and produced by the largest resin supplier in Southeast Asia. Our super gloss formula cures to a perfectly crystal clear finish with no polishing required. It cures hard as a rock and Resists Scratches, Stains and Yellowing. We only offer the best 1:1 ab resin because we are committed to making resin "By Crafters, For Crafters".
Easy 1:1 Mixture: Even beginners will quickly pick up the skill. Only 3 Steps and then you're ready to go. With JDiction 1 1 epoxy, you're always one step ahead. Mix the epoxy resin and hardener with 1:1 volume ratio, Put resin and hardener in warm water for 3 minutes separately to reduce bubbles, then mix,stir slowly until the colour is consistent with no streaks. Work at room temperature and enjoy the LONGER 30 minutes working time that allows for more time for the creative process.
Non-Toxic & Odorless: AB epoxy resin are Zero VOCS and Odor Free. BPA free and Non-flammable. Rigorous testing was done to ensure that resin is a perfect match for craft pigments like most mica and glow pigments. Which is why JDiction epoxy resin is standing out for jewelry making, river tables, and christmas decorations.
Why Choose Us: Formulated in the USA and developed in collaboration with the leading resincrete supplier in Southeast Asia, JDiction epoxy resin ensures both your well-being and the environment's health. With more than 20 years of dedicated experience, explore epoxy resin art materials designed to deliver enduring results. By crafters, for crafters.

8.8

Excellent

Save 5%

We scanned 1112 products

We reviewed these offers relevant to the Heat Resistant Epoxy Resin within online retailers such as Amazon, eBay and other local retailers, ensuring we covered all major brands and models. The products we selected come from trusted brands like Craft Resin, IModeur, Teexpert, LET'S RESIN, LAMXIN, JDiction, all of which have a reputation for consistently delivering high-quality products that users love and innovative approaches for function & design.

For the best Heat Resistant Epoxy Resin in the market, we considered we took a deep dive into 5561 online reviews , focusing on elements like user satisfaction, performance in real-world conditions, and long-term reliability. Our ranking also evaluates each review’s relevancy, authenticity, up-to-dateness and depth so that the comparison is more sound.

We concluded that:

The clear winner of our analysis is CRAFT RESIN 4L Table Top Epoxy Resin Kit – 1:1 Mix, Crystal Clear & High Gloss, UV Resistant, Self-Levelling, Food Safe Resin Epoxy 2 Part for Countertops, DIY Casting, Wood & Art Coating. We love many things about this product by Craft Resin. What sets it apart from the competition is Crystal clear, glass-like finish. , UV resistant for long-lasting use. , User-friendly mix ratio kit. .
The best value product for most shoppers and where user satisfaction is continuously the highest is CRAFT RESIN 1.5L Crystal Clear Deep Pour Epoxy Resin Kit - Food Safe & UV Resistant Best for DIY, Art, River Table, Wood, Flower Preservation, Mould Casting Resin Epoxy Kit - for Beginners & Pros by Craft Resin based on online reviews by bloggers, experts and online shoppers.
The biggest bargain at the moment for Heat Resistant Epoxy Resin and the best cost-to-value ratio is IModeur Epoxy Resin Kit - 128 oz/1 Gallon Self-Leveling Crystal Clear Epoxy Resin - No Yellowing No Bubble UV Resistant Art Resin Casting Resin for Art Crafts, Jewelry Making, Resin Molds (64oz x 2)at IModeur with a 29% discount.
Our list of the best Heat Resistant Epoxy Resin is updated regularly to reflect new releases and changes in product availability, so be sure to check back often for the latest rankings and discounts.

10 Best Heat Resistant Epoxy Resin in The UK

Related Deals You Might Like for Heat Resistant Epoxy Resin

Gorilla Epoxy 25ml

80g Heavy Duty Metal Epoxy Glue | High-Temperature Resistant Up to 300°C | Strong Adhesive for Metal, Plastic, Stainless Steel & Aluminum Alloy | DIY Crafts & Industrial Repairs

Epoxy Resin Crystal Clear Kit -16oz /474ml Casting Resin for Jewellery DIY Art Resin Coating Easy Cast Epoxy, with Instructions/Bonus Sticks/Graduated Cups/Beak Cover

JDiction Epoxy Resin High Gloss - 16OZ Crystal Clear Epoxy Resin Kit, Upgrade Formula, Self Leveling Resin for Jewelry Making, Art, Coasters, Wood, Non-Toxic, UV Resistant, Easy1:1 Ratio

520ml/20oz Epoxy Resin Kit - Self-leveling & Bubbles-Free Crystal Clear Epoxy Resin Kit for DIY Art, Resin Jewellery Making, Table and Countertop Coating, Coasters, Wood - Heat & UV Resistant

J-B Weld 8297 HighHeat Temperature Resistant Epoxy Putty Stick, Machine Gray, 2oz

J-B Weld 8297-DEU HighHeat, Heat-Resistant epoxy Metal Putty for All high Temperature Jobs, Gray, one Size

5 Minute Epoxy Glue 100ml, Universal Clear Epoxy Adhesive for Metal, Plastic, Wood, Ceramics, Glass and More, Sturdy, Waterproof, Heat-Resistant, Fast Curing 2 Part Epoxy Resin Kit

JB Weld Original Cold-Weld 8265-SUK Steel Reinforced Epoxy - Dark Grey (Packaging may vary)

Mouldd 1L Epoxy Resin Kit - Crystal Clear Resin & Hardener for DIY Arts and Crafts - For Making Coasters, Jewellery, Trays, Table Top Coatings - Food Safe, Heat & UV Resistant

We scanned 1112 products

We concluded that: