Best Insinkerator Plug of 2026

Last updated on 06/02/2026

Advertising disclosure

Advertising disclosure

Most Relevant

Electronics Home & Kitchen Computers Office Supplies Toys & Games Sports & Fitness

Most Relevant

InSinkErator 75257 Magnetic Stopper

InSinkErator 75257 Magnetic Stopper

Product image 1

Product image 2

Product image 3

InSinkErator 75257 Magnetic Stopper

Value for Money

75257 Garbage Disposal Stopper Compatible with InSinkErator Cover Control Garbage Disposal Magnetic Stopper, Replaces 75052, 74094, 74052, 74275,Black

75257 Garbage Disposal Stopper Compatible with InSinkErator Cover Control Garbage Disposal Magnetic Stopper, Replaces 75052, 74094, 74052, 74275,Black

Magnetic cover activation switch.
Ensures replacement part compatibility.
Runs only with cover.

Main Highlights

Magnetic Stopper: 75257 Cover Control garbage disposal offers covered operation activated by a magnetic Cover Start switch
Compatible Models: Designed for ISE Cover Control and Pro Cover Control Batch Feed Disposals from Insinkerator
Replacement Part: Replaces part numbers 75052, 74094, 74052, and 74275 for Evolution Cover Control disposals
Safety Feature: Runs only when the cover is on, providing an extra layer of protection during operation
Versatile Fit: Compatible with Insinkerator Cover Control garbage disposals for a secure and reliable replacement

Product image 1

Product image 2

Product image 3

Product image 4

75257 Garbage Disposal Stopper Compatible with InSinkErator Cover Control Garbage Disposal Magnetic Stopper, Replaces 75052, 74094, 74052, 74275,Black

Magnetic cover activation switch.
Ensures replacement part compatibility.
Runs only with cover.

Main Highlights

Magnetic Stopper: 75257 Cover Control garbage disposal offers covered operation activated by a magnetic Cover Start switch
Compatible Models: Designed for ISE Cover Control and Pro Cover Control Batch Feed Disposals from Insinkerator
Replacement Part: Replaces part numbers 75052, 74094, 74052, and 74275 for Evolution Cover Control disposals
Safety Feature: Runs only when the cover is on, providing an extra layer of protection during operation
Versatile Fit: Compatible with Insinkerator Cover Control garbage disposals for a secure and reliable replacement

InSinkErator Black Evolution Series Antimicrobial Quiet Collar Sink Baffle QCB

InSinkErator Black Evolution Series Antimicrobial Quiet Collar Sink Baffle QCB

Offers unique international variety.
Different fit and labelling.
Interesting age ratings.

Main Highlights

Global Store items have separate terms, are sold from abroad, and may differ from the UK version, including fit, age ratings, and labelling.

Product image 1

Product image 2

Product image 3

InSinkErator Black Evolution Series Antimicrobial Quiet Collar Sink Baffle QCB

Offers unique international variety.
Different fit and labelling.
Interesting age ratings.

Main Highlights

Global Store items have separate terms, are sold from abroad, and may differ from the UK version, including fit, age ratings, and labelling.

InSinkErator STP-SS Sink Stopper for Garbage Disposals, Stainless Steel, 3-3/8" ID, 4-1/2 OD

InSinkErator STP-SS Sink Stopper for Garbage Disposals, Stainless Steel, 3-3/8" ID, 4-1/2 OD

Restores original disposal functionality.
Durable polished stainless steel.
Leak-proof with rubber gasket.

Main Highlights

Replaces Lost or Worn Out Stoppers on ISE Disposers
Polished Stainless Steel
Rubber Gasket Ensures Leak Proof Use

Product image 1

InSinkErator STP-SS Sink Stopper for Garbage Disposals, Stainless Steel, 3-3/8" ID, 4-1/2 OD

Restores original disposal functionality.
Durable polished stainless steel.
Leak-proof with rubber gasket.

Main Highlights

Replaces Lost or Worn Out Stoppers on ISE Disposers
Polished Stainless Steel
Rubber Gasket Ensures Leak Proof Use

InSinkErator, Black STP-PL Sink Stopper for Garbage Disposals, 3-3/8" ID, 4-1/2" OD

InSinkErator, Black STP-PL Sink Stopper for Garbage Disposals, 3-3/8" ID, 4-1/2" OD

Perfect fit for all disposers.
Easy to insert and remove.
Keeps sink clean and efficient.

Main Highlights

DRAIN STOPPER: For use with all InSinkErator disposers, the stopper is easy to insert & remove from your sink drain. It fits standard 3-1/2 in. diameter drain openings and comes in a black plastic finish.
PERFECT FIT: This replacement InSinkErator sink stopper is designed to stop water and food particles from going down the drain, allowing you to fill the sink for dishwashing, food preparation & more.
AMERICA'S #1 DISPOSER BRAND: There are more American-built InSinkErator garbage disposals in US homes than all other brands combined. A full line of models means there's one right for every need and budget.
FASTER, CLEANER, SMARTER: From meal prep to cleanup, InSinkErator helps make it fast & easy to keep your kitchen clean with our iconic appliances: garbage disposals & instant hot water dispensers.
A HISTORY OF INNOVATION FOR THE SINK: We invented garbage disposals in 1927, & we're the world’s largest manufacturer of garbage disposals & instant hot water dispensers for home & commercial use.
Replaces Lost or Worn Out Stoppers on ISE Disposers

Product image 1

InSinkErator, Black STP-PL Sink Stopper for Garbage Disposals, 3-3/8" ID, 4-1/2" OD

Perfect fit for all disposers.
Easy to insert and remove.
Keeps sink clean and efficient.

Main Highlights

DRAIN STOPPER: For use with all InSinkErator disposers, the stopper is easy to insert & remove from your sink drain. It fits standard 3-1/2 in. diameter drain openings and comes in a black plastic finish.
PERFECT FIT: This replacement InSinkErator sink stopper is designed to stop water and food particles from going down the drain, allowing you to fill the sink for dishwashing, food preparation & more.
AMERICA'S #1 DISPOSER BRAND: There are more American-built InSinkErator garbage disposals in US homes than all other brands combined. A full line of models means there's one right for every need and budget.
FASTER, CLEANER, SMARTER: From meal prep to cleanup, InSinkErator helps make it fast & easy to keep your kitchen clean with our iconic appliances: garbage disposals & instant hot water dispensers.
A HISTORY OF INNOVATION FOR THE SINK: We invented garbage disposals in 1927, & we're the world’s largest manufacturer of garbage disposals & instant hot water dispensers for home & commercial use.
Replaces Lost or Worn Out Stoppers on ISE Disposers

2 Pack Garbage Disposal Stopper,Sink Stopper for Insinkerator Garbage Disposal,Garbage Disposal Plug for Insinkerator for Moen for Waste King for Whirlaway for Baga for Kitchenaid for Kohler

2 Pack Garbage Disposal Stopper,Sink Stopper for Insinkerator Garbage Disposal,Garbage Disposal Plug for Insinkerator for Moen for Waste King for Whirlaway for Baga for Kitchenaid for Kohler

High-quality, durable material.
Fits multiple standard drains.
Easy to insert/remove.

Main Highlights

【QULITY MATERIAL】: the plug is made of heavy-duty rubber overall, not plastic, and the internal material is high-quality rubber to ensure consistent sealing performance.
【GOOD DESIGN】: Fits standard drains with a diameter of 3 3/8 inches. Our rubbish disposal sink plugs fit for Insinkerator, for Moen, for Waste King,for Whirlaway, for Baga, for Kitchenaid,for Kohler and more.
【HIGH SEALING】: The kitchen sink plug has a good rubber inner layer and fits tightly in the drain when pressed in.
【EASY TO INSERT AND PULL OUT】: The textured surface ensures that the plug will not slip, and the protrusion at the top of the plug provides enough leverage to pull out the plug easily.
【PACKAGE INCLUDES】: 2 * Garbage Disposal Stopper.

Product image 1

Product image 2

Product image 3

Product image 4

2 Pack Garbage Disposal Stopper,Sink Stopper for Insinkerator Garbage Disposal,Garbage Disposal Plug for Insinkerator for Moen for Waste King for Whirlaway for Baga for Kitchenaid for Kohler

High-quality, durable material.
Fits multiple standard drains.
Easy to insert/remove.

Main Highlights

【QULITY MATERIAL】: the plug is made of heavy-duty rubber overall, not plastic, and the internal material is high-quality rubber to ensure consistent sealing performance.
【GOOD DESIGN】: Fits standard drains with a diameter of 3 3/8 inches. Our rubbish disposal sink plugs fit for Insinkerator, for Moen, for Waste King,for Whirlaway, for Baga, for Kitchenaid,for Kohler and more.
【HIGH SEALING】: The kitchen sink plug has a good rubber inner layer and fits tightly in the drain when pressed in.
【EASY TO INSERT AND PULL OUT】: The textured surface ensures that the plug will not slip, and the protrusion at the top of the plug provides enough leverage to pull out the plug easily.
【PACKAGE INCLUDES】: 2 * Garbage Disposal Stopper.

2 Pack Garbage Disposal Stopper,Sink Stopper for Insinkerator Garbage Disposal,Garbage Disposal Plug for Insinkerator,Whirlaway, Baga, Kohler, Moen, Waste King, Kitchenaid and so on.

2 Pack Garbage Disposal Stopper,Sink Stopper for Insinkerator Garbage Disposal,Garbage Disposal Plug for Insinkerator,Whirlaway, Baga, Kohler, Moen, Waste King, Kitchenaid and so on.

Durable heavy-duty rubber material.
Fits most standard sinks.
Provides excellent sealing performance.

Main Highlights

Good Material:The stopper is made of HEAVY-DUTY RUBBER as a whole, NOT PLASTIC,and the internal material is high-quality rubber, ensuring stable sealing performance.
Universal Design:Fits standard 3 3/8 in diameter drain openings.Our replacement sink stopper for garbage disposal is suitable for Insinkerator, Whirlaway, Baga, Kohler, Moen, Waste King, Kitchenaid and so on.
High Sealing:The inner layer of the plug has good rubber, and when you press it in, it can be tightly installed in the sewer.
Easy to Insert and Remove:The textured surface will ensure that the stopper won't become slippery while the protrusion at the top of the stoppers provides adequate leverage to easily pull the stopper out
Includes:2 Sink Stopper

Product image 1

Product image 2

Product image 3

Product image 4

2 Pack Garbage Disposal Stopper,Sink Stopper for Insinkerator Garbage Disposal,Garbage Disposal Plug for Insinkerator,Whirlaway, Baga, Kohler, Moen, Waste King, Kitchenaid and so on.

Durable heavy-duty rubber material.
Fits most standard sinks.
Provides excellent sealing performance.

Main Highlights

Good Material:The stopper is made of HEAVY-DUTY RUBBER as a whole, NOT PLASTIC,and the internal material is high-quality rubber, ensuring stable sealing performance.
Universal Design:Fits standard 3 3/8 in diameter drain openings.Our replacement sink stopper for garbage disposal is suitable for Insinkerator, Whirlaway, Baga, Kohler, Moen, Waste King, Kitchenaid and so on.
High Sealing:The inner layer of the plug has good rubber, and when you press it in, it can be tightly installed in the sewer.
Easy to Insert and Remove:The textured surface will ensure that the stopper won't become slippery while the protrusion at the top of the stoppers provides adequate leverage to easily pull the stopper out
Includes:2 Sink Stopper

2 Pack 3-3/8 Inch Garbage Disposal Stopper, Sink Stopper for Insinkerator Garbage Disposal, Garbage Disposal Plug for Insinkerator, Whirlaway, Baga, Kohler, Moen, Waste King, Kitchenaid

2 Pack 3-3/8 Inch Garbage Disposal Stopper, Sink Stopper for Insinkerator Garbage Disposal, Garbage Disposal Plug for Insinkerator, Whirlaway, Baga, Kohler, Moen, Waste King, Kitchenaid

Durable heavy-duty rubber material.
Fits standard drain sizes.
Easy to insert and remove.

Main Highlights

Good Material: The stopper is made of Heavy-Duty rubber as a whole, not plastic, and the internal material is high-quality rubber, ensuring stable sealing performance.
Universal Design: Fits standard 3 3/8 in diameter drain openings. Our replacement sink stopper for garbage disposal is suitable for Insinkerator, Whirlaway, Baga, Kohler, Moen, Waste King, Kitchenaid and so on.
High Sealing: The inner layer of the plug has good rubber, and when you press it in, it can be tightly installed in the sewer.
Easy to Insert and Remove: The textured surface will ensure that the stopper won't become slippery while the protrusion at the top of the stoppers provides adequate leverage to easily pull the stopper out.
Includes: 2 Sink Stoppers.

Product image 1

Product image 2

Product image 3

Product image 4

2 Pack 3-3/8 Inch Garbage Disposal Stopper, Sink Stopper for Insinkerator Garbage Disposal, Garbage Disposal Plug for Insinkerator, Whirlaway, Baga, Kohler, Moen, Waste King, Kitchenaid

Durable heavy-duty rubber material.
Fits standard drain sizes.
Easy to insert and remove.

Main Highlights

Good Material: The stopper is made of Heavy-Duty rubber as a whole, not plastic, and the internal material is high-quality rubber, ensuring stable sealing performance.
Universal Design: Fits standard 3 3/8 in diameter drain openings. Our replacement sink stopper for garbage disposal is suitable for Insinkerator, Whirlaway, Baga, Kohler, Moen, Waste King, Kitchenaid and so on.
High Sealing: The inner layer of the plug has good rubber, and when you press it in, it can be tightly installed in the sewer.
Easy to Insert and Remove: The textured surface will ensure that the stopper won't become slippery while the protrusion at the top of the stoppers provides adequate leverage to easily pull the stopper out.
Includes: 2 Sink Stoppers.

2 Pack 3-3/8 Inch Garbage Disposal Stopper,Sink Stopper for Insinkerator Garbage Disposal,Garbage Disposal Plug for Insinkerator,Whirlaway,Baga,Kohler,Moen,Waste King,Kitchenaid

2 Pack 3-3/8 Inch Garbage Disposal Stopper,Sink Stopper for Insinkerator Garbage Disposal,Garbage Disposal Plug for Insinkerator,Whirlaway,Baga,Kohler,Moen,Waste King,Kitchenaid

Heavy-duty rubber ensures durability.
Universal fit for multiple brands.
Easy to use and remove.

Main Highlights

Good Material: The stopper is made of Heavy-Duty rubber as a whole, not plastic, and the internal material is high-quality rubber, ensuring stable sealing performance.
Universal Design: Fits standard 3 3/8 in diameter drain openings. Our replacement sink stopper for garbage disposal is suitable for Insinkerator, Whirlaway, Baga, Kohler, Moen, Waste King, Kitchenaid and so on.
High Sealing: The inner layer of the plug has good rubber, and when you press it in, it can be tightly installed in the sewer.
Easy to Insert and Remove: The textured surface will ensure that the stopper won't become slippery while the protrusion at the top of the stoppers provides adequate leverage to easily pull the stopper out.
Includes: 2 Sink Stoppers.

Product image 1

Product image 2

Product image 3

Product image 4

2 Pack 3-3/8 Inch Garbage Disposal Stopper,Sink Stopper for Insinkerator Garbage Disposal,Garbage Disposal Plug for Insinkerator,Whirlaway,Baga,Kohler,Moen,Waste King,Kitchenaid

Heavy-duty rubber ensures durability.
Universal fit for multiple brands.
Easy to use and remove.

Main Highlights

Good Material: The stopper is made of Heavy-Duty rubber as a whole, not plastic, and the internal material is high-quality rubber, ensuring stable sealing performance.
Universal Design: Fits standard 3 3/8 in diameter drain openings. Our replacement sink stopper for garbage disposal is suitable for Insinkerator, Whirlaway, Baga, Kohler, Moen, Waste King, Kitchenaid and so on.
High Sealing: The inner layer of the plug has good rubber, and when you press it in, it can be tightly installed in the sewer.
Easy to Insert and Remove: The textured surface will ensure that the stopper won't become slippery while the protrusion at the top of the stoppers provides adequate leverage to easily pull the stopper out.
Includes: 2 Sink Stoppers.

Anglepingping 2pcs 3 3/8" Garbage Disposal Sink Baffle QCB-AM Splash Guards for Insinkerator,Garbage Disposal Quiet Cover Splash Guard Replacement for InSinkErator Evolution Series,Black

Anglepingping 2pcs 3 3/8" Garbage Disposal Sink Baffle QCB-AM Splash Guards for Insinkerator,Garbage Disposal Quiet Cover Splash Guard Replacement for InSinkErator Evolution Series,Black

Perfect replacement for InSinkErator disposers.
Easy to install and clean.
Reduces noise and splashes.

Main Highlights

Diameter - 3 3/8" , The garbage disposal splash guard replacement is designed replacement for InSinkErator Evolution series waste disposer and many other 3 bolt mount disposers .
Easy to install and clean- No tools are required and the splash guard is removable for easy cleaning and access to the processor grinding hopper.
Made of high-quality rubber, providing you with a quiet and comfortable environment.
The splash guard prevents water and debris from splashing upwards and reduces noise from the disposer. It provides a more comfortable and relaxing kitchen experience.
Package includes: 2x garbage disposal splash guards 3 3/8"(Black).

Product image 1

Product image 2

Product image 3

Product image 4

Anglepingping 2pcs 3 3/8" Garbage Disposal Sink Baffle QCB-AM Splash Guards for Insinkerator,Garbage Disposal Quiet Cover Splash Guard Replacement for InSinkErator Evolution Series,Black

Perfect replacement for InSinkErator disposers.
Easy to install and clean.
Reduces noise and splashes.

Main Highlights

Diameter - 3 3/8" , The garbage disposal splash guard replacement is designed replacement for InSinkErator Evolution series waste disposer and many other 3 bolt mount disposers .
Easy to install and clean- No tools are required and the splash guard is removable for easy cleaning and access to the processor grinding hopper.
Made of high-quality rubber, providing you with a quiet and comfortable environment.
The splash guard prevents water and debris from splashing upwards and reduces noise from the disposer. It provides a more comfortable and relaxing kitchen experience.
Package includes: 2x garbage disposal splash guards 3 3/8"(Black).

We scanned 1743 products

We reviewed these offers relevant to the Insinkerator Plug within online retailers such as Amazon, eBay and other local retailers, ensuring we covered all major brands and models. The products we selected come from trusted brands like InSinkErator, IHOUMEX, LiXiongBao, PeiDog, Mingxiong, Anglepingping, all of which have a reputation for consistently delivering high-quality products that users love and innovative approaches for function & design.

For the best Insinkerator Plug in the market, we considered we took a deep dive into 8716 online reviews , focusing on elements like user satisfaction, performance in real-world conditions, and long-term reliability. Our ranking also evaluates each review’s relevancy, authenticity, up-to-dateness and depth so that the comparison is more sound.

We concluded that:

The clear winner of our analysis is InSinkErator 75257 Magnetic Stopper. We love many things about this product by InSinkErator.
The best value product for most shoppers and where user satisfaction is continuously the highest is 75257 Garbage Disposal Stopper Compatible with InSinkErator Cover Control Garbage Disposal Magnetic Stopper, Replaces 75052, 74094, 74052, 74275,Black by IHOUMEX based on online reviews by bloggers, experts and online shoppers.
The biggest bargain at the moment for Insinkerator Plug and the best cost-to-value ratio is 75257 Garbage Disposal Stopper Compatible with InSinkErator Cover Control Garbage Disposal Magnetic Stopper, Replaces 75052, 74094, 74052, 74275,Blackat IHOUMEX with a 7% discount.
Our list of the best Insinkerator Plug is updated regularly to reflect new releases and changes in product availability, so be sure to check back often for the latest rankings and discounts.